Food costing: the numbers most kitchens never run

A restaurant can be full every night and still lose money. Usually the menu is doing it, one dish at a time.

I came to this from an unusual direction — a food science degree first, restaurant work later. The combination made one thing obvious very quickly: most small restaurants price from the market, not from their own numbers. They look at what the place down the road charges, land somewhere near it, and never check whether that price covers what the dish actually costs them.

Start with the recipe card, not the menu

Every dish needs a written recipe with weights, not descriptions. Not "cheese" — eighty grams of cheese. Not "sauce" — forty millilitres. Until the quantities are written down, three cooks make the same dish three different ways and none of your costs mean anything.

Then cost each line at your actual delivered price, including waste. If you buy a case of tomatoes and trim fifteen percent of it away, your real cost per usable kilo is higher than the invoice says. Yield is where the quiet losses live.

Food cost percentage is a signal, not a target

Divide the dish cost by its menu price. A number in the high twenties or low thirties is a common comfort zone, but the percentage on its own tells you little. A dish at thirty-eight percent that sells two hundred times a week can contribute more cash than a dish at twenty-two percent that sells nine times.

This is why the useful figure is contribution in money, not percentage: menu price minus dish cost, times how many you actually sell. Rent is paid in pounds, not in percentages.

Sort the menu into four groups

Take every item and place it on two axes — how popular it is, and how much cash it contributes. You get four groups, and each one has a different action:

  • Popular and profitable: protect these. Do not change the recipe, do not let quality slip, keep them visible on the menu
  • Popular but thin margin: these are the ones to work on. Re-check portion size, supplier price, or raise the price slightly — popularity gives you room
  • Profitable but ignored: a placement and description problem more than a food problem. Move it, photograph it, let staff recommend it
  • Neither popular nor profitable: remove it. It is consuming stock, prep time and menu space

A price rise is smaller than you think

Owners resist raising prices because they imagine customers watching every item. In practice a five percent rise on a mid-priced dish is a few pounds, and it usually passes unnoticed, while five percent off the top line is very noticeable in the accounts. The risk is concentrated in the two or three signature items people actually remember the price of — leave those alone and move the rest.

Recost every quarter, and whenever a supplier moves

Costing is not a one-time exercise. Supplier prices move, and a menu costed eighteen months ago is describing a restaurant that no longer exists. Put a recurring date in the calendar and treat it as maintenance, not a project.

Read next