What actually decides a technical proposal
Most losing bids are not beaten on price. They are beaten on the three pages the evaluation committee reads most carefully.
Read the articleAn established company's logo is rarely the problem. Usually the problem is everything printed around it.
When a company that has been trading for twenty years asks for a new logo, the request is almost never really about the logo. Something else has gone wrong — the materials look dated next to a competitor's, the files have been lost and everything is a screenshot of a screenshot, or a new generation has taken over and wants the brand to feel like theirs.
Those are three different problems and only one of them is solved by drawing a new mark.
Every year a mark stays in the market, it accumulates recognition you cannot buy back. Clients associate it with contracts that went well. It is on the sign, the stamp, the proposals in someone's archive. Throwing that away for a shape you prefer aesthetically is an expensive trade, and it is usually made on the designer's taste rather than the business's interest.
On the BLI work, the brief was effectively this: the firm had standing in its market and a mark people knew, but the execution had aged — heavy drop shadows, a cramped bilingual lockup, strokes that disappeared at small sizes. The answer was not a new identity. It was the same mark rebuilt properly: the letterforms cleaned and evened, the effects removed, the typography balanced, the descriptor reset so it reads at any size.
Anyone who knew the company still recognized it immediately. That is the test. If regular clients have to be told the logo changed, the refresh was probably right. If they ask who the new company is, you have thrown away the asset.
In most cases the logo is fine and the system around it is missing. No defined colours, so every printer produces a different shade. No typeface rule, so each document uses whatever was installed. No proper file set, so the sign-maker works from a low-resolution image. No template, so every proposal looks like a different company wrote it.
Building that system — colours, type, spacing, a document template, a correct file set — changes how the company looks far more than a new logo would, and it does not spend the recognition you already own.
Audit what exists and where it is used. Fix the file set first. Define the system. Rebuild the materials. Only then, if the mark itself still fails, redraw it — and when you do, redraw it as the same brand, not a different one.
Most losing bids are not beaten on price. They are beaten on the three pages the evaluation committee reads most carefully.
Read the articleA restaurant can be full every night and still lose money. Usually the menu is doing it, one dish at a time.
Read the article